Now, there is an old saying, de gustihus non est disputan-
dum, and consequently every person has a perfect right to
like what pleases him ; so that in this way anyone may
prefer to diink Avhisky, or any other form of spirits, and he
is quite entitled to believe there is nothing so good for him ;
but, on the other hand, an habitual spirit-drinker must not
claim to possess a correct judgment in estimating the quali-
ties of a good wine ; for, as a matter of fact, the daily influ-
ence of whisky on the palate is absolutely fatal to its delicacy
of perception. There are none of the graceful flavours, none
of the delicate ethers, none of the perfumed bouquets in
whisky that belong to a wholesome wine. No, there is only
the coarse spirit which benumbs the palatal nerves, and
renders them incapable of picking out these vinous attri-
butes. Moreover, it would almost seem that a person's
very thoughts are controlled by his customary beverage.
It is evident, indeed, that Eichard Bentley, one of
the greatest scholars of modern times, believed in this
doctrine ; for did he not make this memorable remark
to one of his pupils : " Sir, if you drink ale, you will think
ale"?
AUSTRALIAN WINE. 223
Is it not true, also, that with many people champagne is
regarded as the highest type of wine ? This is more likely
to be the case with those who are beginning to realize the
pleasures of life. Indeed, as it has been acutely remarked,
a youngster from college, when invited to dinner, thinks
himself badly treated if he does not get it. Now, it is not
to be denied that champagne is, in its way, an imperial
drink, and that it has a specially exhilarating effect. But,
at the same time, it must be remembered that it is on the
othet side of the champagne stage of life that the apprecia-
tion of really great wines begins.
Take, for instance, a comparison of the wines of Bordeaux
and of Burgundy. These are two distinct classes of wine,
and, according to Mr. Sept. Berdmore, should be imbibed on
different days. That they are entirely distinct wines might
only be expected, seeing that the geographical positions of
the two districts are so far apart. The Bordeaux wines
come from the south-western or Bay of Biscay side of
France, while those of Burgundy belong to her eastern
portion. It is almost universally a matter of belief that the
red wines of Bordeaux should be warmed gradually — taking
some hours — before they are drunk. The temperature of
these wines should be as nearly as possible the temperature
of the dining-room itself. The finest clarets are often
utterly spoiled from the fact that this has been disregarded,
and they have been brought to table without any prepara-
tion. In the case of Burgundy, however, an opposite treat-
ment is required, and by many connoisseui"s it is considered
to be best when brought up from a cool cellar shortly before
use. All these are matters of considerable importance, and
show that the judging of wines requires something more
than a mere off-hand opinion.
There are certain descriptions of the different varieties of
wines, given by Thudicum and Dnpre, Vizetelly and others,
224 THE ART OF LIVING IN AUSTRALIA.
Page 150
Presented as published in 1893. Historical recipes may not meet modern food-safety standards. Cook from the modern interpretation, not the original instructions.
AI-modernized reading of the original text
Now, there is an old saying, de gustibus non est disputandum, and consequently every person has a perfect right to like what pleases him ; so that in this way anyone may prefer to drink whisky, or any other form of spirits, and he is quite entitled to believe there is nothing so good for him ; but, on the other hand, an habitual spirit-drinker must not claim to possess a correct judgment in estimating the qualities of a good wine ; for, as a matter of fact, the daily influence of whisky on the palate is absolutely fatal to its delicacy of perception. There are none of the graceful flavours, none of the delicate ethers, none of the perfumed bouquets in whisky that belong to a wholesome wine. No, there is only the coarse spirit which benumbs the palatal nerves, and renders them incapable of picking out these vinous attributes. Moreover, it would almost seem that a person's very thoughts are controlled by his customary beverage. It is evident, indeed, that Richard Bentley, one of the greatest scholars of modern times, believed in this doctrine ; for did he not make this memorable remark to one of his pupils : " Sir, if you drink ale, you will think ale"?
Is it not true, also, that with many people champagne is regarded as the highest type of wine ? This is more likely to be the case with those who are beginning to realize the pleasures of life. Indeed, as it has been acutely remarked, a youngster from college, when invited to dinner, thinks himself badly treated if he does not get it. Now, it is not to be denied that champagne is, in its way, an imperial drink, and that it has a specially exhilarating effect. But, at the same time, it must be remembered that it is on the other side of the champagne stage of life that the appreciation of really great wines begins.
Take, for instance, a comparison of the wines of Bordeaux and of Burgundy. These are two distinct classes of wine, and, according to Mr. Sept. Berdmore, should be imbibed on different days. That they are entirely distinct wines might only be expected, seeing that the geographical positions of the two districts are so far apart. The Bordeaux wines come from the south-western or Bay of Biscay side of France, while those of Burgundy belong to her eastern portion. It is almost universally a matter of belief that the red wines of Bordeaux should be warmed gradually — taking some hours — before they are drunk. The temperature of these wines should be as nearly as possible the temperature of the dining-room itself. The finest clarets are often utterly spoiled from the fact that this has been disregarded, and they have been brought to table without any preparation. In the case of Burgundy, however, an opposite treatment is required, and by many connoisseurs it is considered to be best when brought up from a cool cellar shortly before use. All these are matters of considerable importance, and show that the judging of wines requires something more than a mere off-hand opinion.
There are certain descriptions of the different varieties of wines, given by Thudicum and Dupre, Vizetelly and others,