FoodNet

Macaroni and Cheese without Eggs

From Cooking for profit, 1886

Serves 2

The flour thickening added is to form a sort of sauce, but not enough to cake the macaroni together.

Presented as published in 1886. Historical recipes may not meet modern food-safety standards. Cook from the modern interpretation below, not the original instructions.

A modern interpretation · AI-generated from the original record

Ingredients

Method

As published

This recipe was extracted from Cooking for profit (1886) by Jessup Whitehead, page 193. The excerpt below is the record exactly as published.

Macaroni and Cheese without Eggs. . "I never could understand,** said Mrs. Tingee, one day, "how the Italians can be so poor, as the papers say they are, and yet eat so much macaroni as the pa- pers tell us they do : I should think it would break them up buying eggs to cook it with. But then," she added reflectively, * 'sometimes the papers say things that ain't so. Do you cook macaroni some- times?" "Yes ma'am, quite often." "Do you put cheese initi", "Yes.'' "And eggs?" "Yes ; and butter and milk and toma- toes and gravy and oysters and chicken and many more things." "Ah; I had a girl once who wanted to make a dish of macaroni and I kept lay- ing off to get the things together, but, somehow, I never did. Do you know, a friend of mine told me she once knew a hotel cook who never made a dish of macaroni without putting eight eggs in it ! Do you think that "/as true?" "Yes, ma'am ; and I have no doubt but that there are hotel cooks who will even use as many as twelve, or thirteen." Then Mrs. Tingee said, "O, myl" It is a singular trait in this lady that she never seems to regard the difference between a dish for two hundred people and a dish for two or three; all she sees is the eight eggs gone at one fell swoop. 1 venture the opinion that the Italians eat macaroni alone or in soup or gravy without much thought of cheese and without any thought of eggs, and I doubt V3ry much whether many of them would touch the dry and heavy cake of macaroni and cheese that is seen at many hotel tables in this country. There is a good example of an Italian way of preparing macaroni, spaghetti, lassagnes, hdilini and other such pastes at our No. 65; which requires neither eggs nor butter, and here is another just as good : Yi pound macaroni. 2 or 3 ounces cheese — or a grated cup- ful. 3 or 4 basting spoonfuls of fat from the roasting meat. 2 cups water or milk. 2 spoonfuls flour thickening. A handful of crushed crackers
Read the full page as publishedCollapse the page

Cook this with the app: pantry check, scaling, and the assistant.